AN INSIGHT INTO COLLECTING SINISTRAL SHELLS by Carl Ruscoe

Turbinellidae Tudivasum armigerum, A Adams 1855, Keppel Bay Australia

A sinistral shell is a shell of a gastropod which is 'left-handed'. The shell is coiled in an anti-clockwise direction, so that when viewed from the front (ventral view) with the spire uppermost, the opening or 'aperture' appears on the left. The concept of sinistral shells has fascinated countless shell collectors over the years. Just as the majority of humans are right-handed, gastropod molluscs follow a similar trend and a left-handed shell is something of an oddity. Although there are many species which produce left-handed shells, particularly amongst land snails, they can still look rather strange to the conchologist.

To myself, a sinistral shell somehow looks as if it is 'incomplete'. Sinistral shells strike all collectors differently, but nevertheless most experienced collectors will say that they seem anything but normal.

My brother Craig and I have been collecting shells for about 20 years, but it took 10 years of collecting before we saw our first sinistral specimenl Very few 'run-of-the-mill' shell shops at seaside resorts offer any sinistral shells for sale, and in most cases this is where a young collector first becomes attracted to seashells as a hobby. Until we were about 14 years old it did not occur to us that all our gastropod shells coiled in a clockwise direction, and we did not even imagine that a shell could coil the other way so as to be 'left-handed'. When we realised this we became eager to obtain our first 'lefty' ...

From the Macdonald Encyclopaedia of Shells (1982) we picked out the common European tadpole snail, Physa fontinalis, and we set out to find it. We waded through the local brook until we found a similar species: Physa acuta. The first specimen I found crumbled in my hand and I was devastated; but I knew I could find another, and sure enough we found several. This was the start of my fascination with sinistral shells.

Most beginners in shell collecting, who tend to be children, cannot afford to pay a fortune for shells that are abnormally sinistral ('sinistral freaks'). There are, however, several families of molluscs which normally produce left-handed shells. In this article I have described such families for the benefit of beginners and low budget collectors who are looking to add a few of these left-handed oddities to their collection.

Freshwater snails
Most freshwater shells tend to be colourless and unattractive. However, the most easily obtained sinistral shells in the UK are found in freshwater. These snails belong to the genus Physa (family Physidae) and are commonly known as 'tadpole snails'. Most species grow to no more than 15mm in length and are thin fragile shells; they are drab olive-to-brown in colour, sometimes with a whitish columella. They prefer to live in muddy, slow-flowing lowland streams.

There are several other families of freshwater snails which can produce sinistral shells, including Planorbidae, Ampullariidae, Thiaridae and Lymnaeidae. However, these are not as readily obtainable to the novice collector, and in fact some of these snails live in dangerous parts of the world where the water is badly polluted and can contain deadly parasites.

Corona regalis, Hupe 1857, Meruni, Mata Grosso, Brasil

Terrestrial snails
As a rule, terrestrial snails (land snails) can produce a much greater range of colours in their shells than freshwater or brackish snails. This, along with many other features, makes the land snails more appealing to most collectors. There is also a wider variety of left-handed species in the land snail category. In the UK the most easily obtained sinistral land snails belong to the family Clausiliidae (the 'door snails'). These are small turret-Iike snails which can be found at the base of trees in damp deciduous woodland. The British species tend to be brownish in colour and rarely grow to more than 20mm in length. Other sinistral snails to be found in Europe come from families such as Chondrinidae, Buliminidae and Vertiginidae.

The most familiar sinistral snails from tropical regions are the Amphidromus snails of family Camaenidae. These snails produce a wonderful range of colours and patterns and are reasonably cheap. Most of the more common species can be purchased from dealers for a very few pounds, and there is probably no better way to start a land snail collection. Many other families of land snails from tropical regions have some left-handed species, including Achatinellidae, Partulidae, Orthalicidae, Achatinidae, Helixarionidae, Helicidae and Bradybaenidae.

Marine gastropods
In seashells left-handedness is a far rarer occurrence; there are only a few families which normally produce sinistral shells

Busycon carica, Gmelin 1791, Fernandina Florida

The largest sinistral species of gastropod is the lightning whelk, Busycon contrarium. This species can grow to nearly 400mm in length and is common off the southeastern coasts of the USA. There are a few similar species in the genus Busycon which secrete a sinistral shell, but also several dextral (right-handed) species in this same genus. Another easily obtainable family of sinistral shells are the Triphoridae. These are small turret-like shells which are mostly less than 20mm in length. They can be found in most warm and tropical seas and are often seen on dealers' lists costing £1-4. One species, Triphora perversa, is actually quite common in shell grit on some Mediterranean shores

The family Buccinidae (cold water whelks) contains several species whose shells are sinistral; however, most of these are rather rare and expensive. There is only one sinistral species which is reasonably common: Neptunea contraria, a native of the Mediterranean which can sometimes be purchased for less than £10.

Sinistralia is a genus of the family Fasciolariidae (the spindle whelks). As the name suggests, their shells are sinistral. They are interesting little shells, usually about 20mm in length, and most of them can be obtained fairly cheaply. Among the largest molluscan family, the Turridae, one genus is associated with sinistral shells: Antiplanes. The cold water species Antiplanes major and A. contraria are probably the best known, and while neither is expensive to buy they may be difficult to find on dealers' lists. Interestingly, some members of the genus Antiplanes, such as A. sanctioannis, are actually dextral!

Sinistral Freaks
So far, I have discussed species of shell which are normally sinistral. However, 'sinistral freaks' can occur from an array of gastropod species (land and marine) which are normally dextral. No one knows exactly what causes a gastropod to secrete a sinistral shell, but it must be understood that in the majority of cases the whole animal is sinistral. From a very early age in a gastropod's lifecycle, its body undergoes 'torsion'. This is the process of the animal twisting so that it continues to grow in a coiling fashion, around a central axis called the columella. In the case of a sinistral individual, the body has twisted 'the wrong way' -anti-clockwise as opposed to clockwise -and the shell is then secreted to house this left-handed snail, also coiling in an anti-clockwise direction.

Freak sinistral examples of normally dextral species are highly prized by collectors. The most famous of such freaks is the sinistral chank shell of the species Turbinella pyrum. The normal right-handed form of this species is extremely common in India and Sri Lanka, but sinistral specimens are extremely rare and are revered by Hindus. A specimen could cost well over £1000. Even rarer in family Vasidae would be a sinistral specimen of Tudivasum armigera.

Marginella lineolata, Jefferys Bay, South Africa

Jeffreys Bay in South Africa is a well known site for sinistral freaks, for some reason. Occasionally a sinistral cowrie gets washed ashore and even in poor beached condition it will fetch well over £1000. Also, species of the families Marginellidae and Olividae produce sinistral freaks on this beach

Freak left-handed Conus are exceedingly rare, and yet the fossil record shows us that left-handedness was at one time 'the norm' for many species in family Conidae. Indeed, the collector wishing to purchase some inexpensive sinistral shells can quite easily obtain fossil species from Florida such as Conus adversarius, C. osceolai and C. Lindajoyceae.

Left-handed freaks available to the low budget collector include the volute Cymbiola vesperlilio and the marginella Volvarina philippinarum. These sinistral forms are found in the Philippines and are not too expensive to buy; Volvarina philippinarum is the most common sinistral freak by far, and sells for less than £10.

Interestingly, just as there are sinistral freaks, dextral freaks can occur of species which are normally sinistral. Such freaks are of special interest to the collector. An example is the normally sinistral Busycon sinistrum, which occasionally occurs dextrally coiled.

Turbinella pyrum, Linneaus 1758, SE India

The vast majority of sinistral freaks command high prices and many are known by just one or two specimens. With the help of fellow conchologist Simon Aiken I have made a list of some of the better known examples of sinistral freaks. This list is far from complete, but it is intended to give an idea of the diversity of normally right-handed species which have occasionally defied the rules of nature and produced a left-handed shell. The majority of sinistral freaks belong to the order Neogastropoda (the 'new gastropods'). In particular, the families Olividae, Marginellidae and Volutidae produce the most sinistral freaks.

I wish to thank the following for their help with this article: UK shell dealer Simon Aiken for his input and advice; Harry Lee of the Jacksonville Shell Club, Florida, for permission to reproduce pictures of sinistral freaks from his amazing collection; and the Jacksonville club's webmaster Bill Frank for supplying the images.

The magnificient Harry Lee collection of sinistral shells can be seen on the Jacksonville website Sinistral Shells, Harry Lee


The better known marine sinistral freaks

Cypraea		Cypraea capensis Gray, 1828
			Cypraea edentula Gray, 1825
			Cypraea fuscodentata Gray, 1825
Murex			Chicoreus cichoreum Gmelin, 1791
			Nucella lapillus Linnaeus, 1758
Buccinidae		Buccinum undatum Linnaeus, 1758
			Neptunea antiqua Linnaeus, 1758
Melongenidae	Busycon canaliculatus Linnaeus, 1758
			Busycon carica Gmelin, 1791
			Volema myristica Roding, 1798
Volutidae		Cymbiola vespertilio Linnaeus, 1758
			Cymbium cucumis Roding, 1798
Vasidae		Turbinella pyrum Linnaeus, 1758
			Turbinella turbinellus Linnaeus, 1758
Olividae		Ancilla albozonata E.A. Smith, 1904
Marginellidae	Marginella lutea Jousseaume, 1884
			Marginella piperata Hinds, 1844
			Prunum apicinum Menke, 1826
			Volvarina philippinarum Redfield, 1848
Conidae		Conus furvus von Born, 1778
			Conus ventricosus Gmelin, 1791

This web page was last updated on 31 August 2003
Copyright of all images remains with the originator and the British Shell Collectors Club and may not be copied without their expressed permission
Copyright© 2003 British Shell Collectors' Club All rights reserved.

Bullet2 Return to the top Bullet2

Bullet2 Homepage Bullet2